How to pay for a NYC roof deck without a huge assessment

Headshot of Emily Myers
By Emily Myers  |
July 20, 2020 - 9:30AM

A finished roof can be a valuable addition to a building—especially when other shared amenities present health risks.

Zumper via StreetEasy

Most shared amenities at New York City apartment buildings are closed to prevent the spread of coronavirus. Roof decks, however, are places where residents can be outside safely and top many New Yorkers' NYC apartment wishlists as a result of the pandemic. 

Even if a renovated roof is not in your building's capital plan, many boards are seeing if this is something they can offer their shareholders or apartment owners and at the same time add value to the building. 

Many New Yorkers quit the city when the coronavirus case numbers began to rise, and that exodus has worried many boards concerned about resales, particularly those in Manhattan, says Richard Klein, a partner at the law firm Romer Debbas.

"To the extent that a board can make their building more desirable, having roof space helps—it can be a really beautiful addition," he says.

Low interest rates are another reason why now is a good time to upgrade a building's roof. Even so, they are expensive projects—here are a few ways you might be able to pare down the cost and avoid hefty assessments or sizable temporary common charge increases. 

Borrowing and refinancing 

Condos and co-op boards are both able to borrow money to do capital projects and one way of avoiding hefty increases to your maintenance in a co-op is to refinance. 

"No one wants to come out of pocket for thousands of dollars, especially in today’s financial climate," says Harley Seligman, senior vice president at National Cooperative Bank (a Brick Underground sponsor). A co-op can leverage the land and the building as an asset and borrow against it.

"Depending on how low they want their monthly payments to be, the majority of our borrowers for co-ops take a 10-year, fixed-rate loan spread over a 30-year amortization—so it is a balloon payment at which time they can refinance to a new loan," Seligman says.  

Klein says when refinancing, rates are so low that even with a payment penalty, the rate difference means buildings are "paying pretty close to or less than what they were paying before."
In a condo, the loan product is different and the common charges are the collateral for the loan. It's a decision the board and community makes together but Seligman points out, if you are borrowing for the amenity and spreading it over five or 10 years, it's not just the current owners who pay. "If you have new owners, they take on that debt too," he says.

Selling some space

In some buildings, the roof space is only accessibly to the owner or shareholder on the top floor. One Upper East Side resident tells Brick Underground that her 70-unit building sold the roof to the penthouse owner several years ago—something she now sees as a missed opportunity. "One building two blocks up just did their large roof over and they created a netted play space for kids and put up a very large screen to show movies up there in the summer," she says.

If a building doesn't want to create a shared space, one option is to sell portions of the roof space. In smaller buildings with three or four units, it might be possible for each apartment owner or shareholder to have a portion of the roof. In buildings with more units, only some owners will be able to own roof space.

"If the space is large enough to partition, you can allocate shares, sell the space and charge maintenance every month and that's a way for the building to get some extra income," Klein says. 

Depending on the type of space you want and whether you have views (and might lose them if your neighbor builds higher), selling air rights might be an option. 

"If you have air rights to sell, that’s something you could do, and use that money—but that might hurt you because if your neighbor goes up higher, you might lose some of the appeal," says Klein. 

Grants and loans

There are abatements and incentives available to buildings who want to install green roofs on multi-family buildings. Most green roofs are designed to save on energy costs rather than provide recreational space. However, Klein says these grants and loans are worth considering.

"That’s something that should always be explored and done if possible, but it doesn't seem like the programs would result in a roof that is conducive to hanging out with a glass of wine," he says. 


Headshot of Emily Myers

Emily Myers

Senior Writer/Podcast Producer

Emily Myers is a senior writer, podcast host, and producer at Brick Underground. She writes about issues ranging from market analysis and tenants' rights to the intricacies of buying and selling condos and co-ops. As host of the Brick Underground podcast, she has earned four silver awards from the National Association of Real Estate Editors.

Brick Underground articles occasionally include the expertise of, or information about, advertising partners when relevant to the story. We will never promote an advertiser's product without making the relationship clear to our readers.